TechRepublic : A ZDNet Tech Community

Microsoft Windows

Host: Mark Kaelin
Contact

In a series of poll questions, IT professionals made it quite clear that they were not interested in migrating away from Windows XP. What do the results mean for your organization?

———————————————————————–

A couple of weeks ago, I asked a series of poll questions about Microsoft Windows XP. That single blog post lead to close to 300 separate posts in the corresponding discussion thread. The poll results are very informative and definitely give us an indication about where the TechRepublic membership stands with regard to a potential operating system migration.

To put it politely and succinctly — most IT professionals are not looking forward to it. In fact, many are actively and passionately against the very idea.

Let’s take a deeper look at the results and see what we can glean with regard to the future of Windows XP.

This blog post is also available in PDF format in a free TechRepublic download.

Results

Figure A

Obviously there is a large installed base of Windows XP deployed worldwide.

Figure B

It looks like the real loser in this poll question is Windows Vista. The vast majority of respondents are either waiting for Windows 7 or planning to keep Windows XP.

Another interesting data point is the lack of consideration for Linux or Mac OS X. Despite what vocal and passionate proponents of those operating systems may advocate, IT professionals in the business space are only interested in Windows — at least for right now.

Figure C

Backing up the previous result is this question regarding which operating systems have been tested as a possible replacement for XP. A decent percentage of IT professionals have tested the potential of Linux, but the majority of respondents are still squarely in the Windows camp.

Figure D

While legacy applications are definitely a major consideration, they don’t seem to be the major obstacle to operating system migration.

Figure E

This is the first poll question to deal with the actual practical deployment of a new operating system. It is abundantly obvious that many IT professionals are not ready to implement a migration. Unless there is a catalyst that cannot be ignored, Windows XP is going to remain the primary operating system for many organizations for as long as it is feasible.

The discussion thread following the first blog post backs the response to this question. Many posters in the discussion were determined to keep Windows XP as absolutely long as they can.

Figure F

The two primary reasons Windows XP looks destined to remain a factor for some time to come is that it works and that Vista is not perceived as a viable replacement. Without some sort of catalyst to force a migration, the deployment of any operating system besides XP will be slow and methodical.

Format G

The concept of a methodical rollout is confirmed by the results of this poll question. Most IT professionals have no plans to roll out a company-wide deploy of a new operating system. Rather, new operating systems, if they are to be introduced at all into an organization, are mostly likely going to trickle in with new equipment.

Figure H

Once again, we see in the response to this poll question that operating systems other than some form of Windows are not really being considered. The implication is that IT professionals have very little interest in migrating away from Windows XP no matter what other operating system you ask them to consider.

Bottom line

Looking over the poll results, it leaves little doubt that the general consensus is against operating system migration until it is absolutely necessary. Windows XP is working just fine for many and, so far, no feasible or practical reason has presented itself as a catalyst that will drive IT professionals to consider a change. It looks like Windows XP is going to be around for longer than Microsoft may have suspected.

Stay on top of the latest XP tips and tricks with TechRepublic’s Windows XP newsletter, delivered every Thursday. Automatically sign up today!

Mark Kaelin is a CBS Interactive Senior Editor for TechRepublic. He is the host for the Microsoft Windows blog, Product Spotlight blog, and the editor for Cracking Open Photo Galleries. Read his full bio and profile. You can also follow him on Twitter.

Print/View all Posts Comments on this blog

Head in the sand? Mark W. KaelinTechrepublic Moderator | 07/01/09
Consumers rule, Microsoft drools SilverBullet | 07/01/09
Of course! mjc5@... | 07/02/09
Can't put it any better. wyattharris@... | 07/02/09
That doesn't alter the fact that things change mwagner@... | 07/02/09
Change is inevitable j.phetteplace@... | 07/02/09
Windows 7 is just a revision of Windows Vista ocie3@... | 07/02/09
Windows 7 is more than a Vista revision jeffv96818 | 07/03/09
Just like... JasonJD48 | 07/06/09
95 had USB support.... SinisterSlay | 07/07/09
Someting faster, better stuff Flashtube105 | 07/06/09
RE: Someting faster, better stuff Rhodent | 07/06/09
Not a bottleneck for many if not most rcfoulk@... | 07/08/09
I Agree kmdennis@... | 07/12/09
Also Agree lucien86@... | 07/18/09
Or, as they say at my high school.... RipVan | 07/15/09
not so fast, mwagner SilverBullet | 07/02/09
Agreed. Market driven FatNGristle | 07/02/09
Change? Rhodent | 07/05/09
Yes, things change. But... littlepd | 07/02/09
M$ Litigation for Not Upgrading tonycopp@... | 07/02/09
The planet? DWalker88001 | 07/14/09
@DWalker88001 tech@... | 07/15/09
Resistance is futile! DragonRider_65@... | 07/03/09
you pleasure yourself indeed tonycopp@... | 07/04/09
but when does it end pdm_pdq@... | 07/02/09
Thats true of the industry and many other industries JasonJD48 | 07/06/09
Yes, things change, but . . . darwin@... | 07/02/09
I generally agree Rhodent | 07/05/09
Microsoft's decision, not ours ocie3@... | 07/02/09
You are forgetting mypl8s4u2 | 07/03/09
Boy you read me wrong! mjc5@... | 07/03/09
Not necessarily kmdennis@... | 07/03/09
XP may be the last windows I run VikingCoder | 08/17/09
My thoughts exactly nelsonhoover | 08/18/09
OS transition broken n.champaigne@... | 07/09/09
How to make the Definitive Windows upgrade mjc5@... | 07/10/09
Check out these options!...Seriously maclovin | 07/01/09
CALs maclovin | 07/01/09
the #'s sk.dunnage@... | 07/01/09
Old School robertmro | 07/02/09
whuut? mark@... | 07/02/09
Don't wonder around without your security blanket SilverBullet | 07/02/09
The next generation are much more open minded... rfolden@... | 07/03/09
..... lucien86@... | 07/18/09
Next gen vicden@... | 07/21/09
Not that I minded.... maclovin | 10/29/09
So The 'G-Man.' | 07/02/09
Exactly! Darryl~ | 07/03/09
Mac in real world lan!? samhain.knight@... | 07/02/09
Wow... maclovin | 07/10/09
The flaw in your reasoning ... mwagner@... | 07/02/09
Mac uses Intel/Nvidia Freewaresucks@... | 07/07/09
Too Many Difficulties dan.wildcat@... | 07/03/09
Not direct attack on you... maclovin | 07/10/09
XP and the why fix it (if it aint broke)mentality gorman.mi@... | 07/01/09
Business model husserl@... | 07/02/09
So your saying Freewaresucks@... | 07/07/09
Sadly... maclovin | 07/10/09
Hear Hear !!!!! capewaydesign@... | 07/03/09
XP is good oracat86@... | 07/02/09
Nothing wrong with XP erinsdad | 07/02/09
Agreed Darryl~ | 07/03/09
my head is in the sand andrew.lawlor@... | 07/02/09
HARDWARE & Economy rkendsley | 07/02/09
That was my first thought, as well MikeG3b | 07/02/09
Victim of Success Dogcatcher | 07/02/09
um....no brrla@... | 07/02/09
We are not afraid of change... ginny@... | 07/02/09
Head in the clouds! tonycopp@... | 07/02/09
Inertia, Prejudice and Ignorance grax | 07/03/09
Inertia, Prejudice, and Ignorace redux tonycopp@... | 07/03/09
Inertia, Prejudice, and Ignorance redux tonycopp@... | 07/03/09
Having said that, WTF is your point? grax | 07/03/09
no edit function: "Ignorance" was spelled incorrectly tonycopp@... | 07/03/09
Vista / W7 percieved as bad by SME's maidens@... | 07/03/09
I'm not belittling Win7... sykandtyed | 07/03/09
In My Experience and Some Rambling Thoughts dan.wildcat@... | 07/03/09
And what if the B.Boss is orrified how much he have to learn ? alainch@... | 07/12/09
Head in the Sand - You hit the nail on the head desirawson@... | 07/04/09
WOW -Someone desn't know business or IT. tech@... | 07/05/09
That dirty word! grax | 07/05/09
The Voice of Reason gorman.mi@... | 07/06/09
XP seems alright but all ralphsabean@... | 07/05/09
It's about software spareher | 07/05/09
Software sales is about installed base, not futures tonycopp@... | 07/06/09
agree Snuffy09 | 07/07/09
Yes, but not now dshorn@... | 07/07/09
Who Wants to Migrate - Period? Brian Doe | 07/11/09
Migration for a reaason? mjc5@... | 07/22/09
No head in the sand , eyes wide open. ramnet@... | 08/13/09
M$FT in more than small bit of denial tonycopp@... | 08/19/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) Bob Oso | 07/01/09
The Redmond Tea Party saghaulor@... | 07/02/09
Multi-tasking O.S. sdavis4fun@... | 07/03/09
XP version 2 jdavis@... | 07/03/09
interesting. csmith.kaze | 07/01/09
I hope so too jck | 07/01/09
The big Switch chrisganderampy@... | 07/02/09
Ubuntu tools for mdb and project files jdah5@... | 07/02/09
Open project is nearly correct chrisganderampy@... | 07/02/09
It may appear so kmdennis@... | 07/12/09
I would be interested in the industry or type of business SilverBullet | 07/01/09
We'd switch to Linux TODAY but for this: finkey@... | 07/02/09
Alternative to QuickBooks (GNUCash?) bobp@... | 07/02/09
Quickbooks VS GNUCash kenneth_hedin2000@... | 07/03/09
Autocad is what's holding us back from any change cjlynge@... | 07/02/09
Agree, AUTODESK has always followed the Windows SilverBullet | 07/02/09
How about Bricscad? good god | 07/03/09
I hear you Darryl~ | 07/03/09
Me too . . . nelsonhoover | 07/03/09
gnucash - maybe tbrucato@... | 07/03/09
Virtualized TripleII | 07/03/09
Catch-22 Brian Doe | 07/12/09
I was recently at The Scummy One | 07/01/09
yeah jck | 07/01/09
Not limited to MS... WTRT | 07/02/09
Typical MS Hype Darryl~ | 07/03/09
Funny Indeed ardz_dhy@... | 07/08/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) peter.j.boyles@... | 07/01/09
Answer. Erik@... | 07/01/09
Change sk.dunnage@... | 07/01/09
Out Of My Cold Dead Hands steve@... | 07/02/09
Remembering UK colleges mhorsman@... | 07/03/09
Sounds irresponsible kmdennis@... | 07/12/09
Security!!! RipVan | 07/08/09
Security!!! Sisyphus and M$isyphus tonycopp@... | 07/08/09
Don't want to change? tracy.walters@... | 07/02/09
There's the real catch. wyattharris@... | 07/02/09
Is forced change really success? doug@... | 07/02/09
RE: Is forced change really success? wbranch@... | 07/02/09
Change when needed ardz_dhy@... | 07/08/09
Clearly I'm very much in the minority david.valdez@... | 07/02/09
Sweet deal!! kmdennis@... | 07/12/09
Actually... david.valdez@... | 08/17/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) buck@... | 07/02/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) richardstevenhack@... | 07/02/09
Ummm, but!!! steve@... | 07/02/09
Ummm, but!!! scarl@... | 07/02/09
RE: If you don't tell them wbranch@... | 07/02/09
Need a good business reason to change swohlers | 07/03/09
Steve, You're dead wrong john3347@... | 07/02/09
Concur Dogcatcher | 07/02/09
RE: Steve, You're dead wrong RBiT | 07/02/09
RE: Computer AS a project = Linux Brian Doe | 07/12/09
Personally it always amazes me... JasonJD48 | 07/06/09
Yes, that does say it all... bblackmoor@... | 07/07/09
Perhaps you should know a little something before you speak on it. saghaulor@... | 07/07/09
Take the blinders off! tech@... | 07/08/09
Picking nits. Palmetto | 07/08/09
Hasn't Windows NT always worked that way? SinisterSlay | 07/08/09
SS, yes. Palmetto | 07/09/09
True, but my point still stands (I think) tech@... | 07/09/09
You Get what You Pay For? Brian Doe | 07/12/09
So your saying what 1/2 of Windows Users have tried linux? tech@... | 07/08/09
A random sampling of people in my life shows 100% have tried Linux SinisterSlay | 07/08/09
We clearly move in different circles. Palmetto | 07/08/09
People remember SinisterSlay | 07/08/09
most users do not care about the OS bblackmoor@... | 07/03/09
Wow hard to install 3rd party apps? SinisterSlay | 07/02/09
Linux is great ... but reisen55@... | 07/03/09
Couldn't disagree more JasonJD48 | 07/06/09
Windows XP ralphsabean@... | 07/02/09
Ubuntu Rhodent | 07/19/09
"Alternatives" rngunter@... | 07/02/09
True, you have to use the right tool for the job tech@... | 07/02/09
Windows XP works, Vista is dirt, 7 is new reisen55@... | 07/02/09
My company is stuck with XP kraterz | 07/02/09
sp2 is the last stop for me brrla@... | 07/05/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) ramnet@... | 07/02/09
RE: Why not improve XP? wbranch@... | 07/02/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) wyldwezl | 07/02/09
NT 4 compatability peter.j.boyles@... | 07/03/09
Why change XP? michael.burgess@... | 07/02/09
Backbone has NOTHING to do with it RosaNegra | 07/02/09
Backbone has NOTHING to do with it michael.burgess@... | 07/02/09
who's funding the new rollout? What industry (type)? SilverBullet | 07/02/09
This is not about Microsoft ... mwagner@... | 07/02/09
The truth about Gates, MS, DOS, and the story SilverBullet | 07/02/09
I'm one of the ones... MyopicOne | 07/02/09
Really interesting wjl@... | 07/02/09
I LOVED that story RipVan | 07/08/09
doesn't work that way LocoLobo | 07/02/09
The boss and the purse strings michael.burgess@... | 07/02/09
Linux as an alternative ... mwagner@... | 07/02/09
State Governments and Linux.. michael.burgess@... | 07/02/09
Now, how about a business that's converted? Palmetto | 07/07/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) pohsibkcir | 07/02/09
Common Sensse at last toecutta@... | 07/04/09
We have reviewed it and most have rejected it. tech@... | 07/05/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) clarnT | 07/02/09
Badly worded question re Linux/Mac DWalker88001 | 07/02/09
Looking Forward to Windows 7 Migration!! samhain.knight@... | 07/02/09
Free??? Check again!! john3347@... | 07/03/09
Funny thought SinisterSlay | 07/03/09
some assumptions are better than others bblackmoor@... | 07/03/09
Not a survey Mark W. KaelinTechrepublic Moderator | 07/03/09
Yes, but... DWalker88001 | 07/18/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) mwagner@... | 07/02/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) melias@... | 07/02/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) pinu_aiub@... | 07/02/09
7 Just makes NO real sense dang@... | 07/02/09
XP support from MS sk.dunnage@... | 07/02/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) pdm_pdq@... | 07/02/09
The cold reality of it all. rick@... | 07/02/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) aazx@... | 07/02/09
If PC industry really wanted to grow... myjunk53@... | 07/02/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) KevinKn | 07/02/09
Question cbadger1@... | 07/02/09
Your wrong,,,, all the R&D at MS in not on the desktop SilverBullet | 07/02/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) skhemithat@... | 07/02/09
If Ever? gbentley@... | 07/02/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) AlJGCT@... | 07/02/09
Not "We, Just "You" gbentley@... | 07/03/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) sms2@... | 07/03/09
Not going to happen anytime soon... george.hickey@... | 07/03/09
WE ARE MICROSOFT! - RESISTANCE IS FUTILE!! Photogenic Memory | 07/03/09
Users are tired Dogcatcher | 07/03/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) craig@... | 07/03/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) clehofer@... | 07/03/09
Test test test. Dyalect | 07/03/09
Kick the Tires... SinisterSlay | 07/03/09
When I was in college, Palmetto | 07/07/09
Shoud look closer at that "other - 11%" fernando@... | 07/03/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) cd003284@... | 07/03/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) dshorn@... | 07/03/09
All true, but Datacommguy | 07/03/09
I still have lots of customers using DOS, Windows 95 and Windows 98. Larry63 | 07/03/09
Still using... eHC1019 | 07/07/09
There is nothing to gain by upgrading AV . | 07/03/09
Why throw away Win XP kumvinod@... | 07/03/09
Graphics hard to read strattonroy@... | 07/04/09
Not a graphics artist Mark W. KaelinTechrepublic Moderator | 07/07/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) n.champaigne@... | 07/05/09
There is an attempt at an open-source Win clone nelsonhoover | 07/08/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) badders46 | 07/05/09
Compelling Reason For Change? steve@... | 07/06/09
'Burning Bush' experience tonycopp@... | 07/06/09
FRee Windows 7 Upgrade for Current Users Ed.Carden@... | 07/06/09
I believe there is such an offer, but Palmetto | 07/07/09
That doesn't make sense tech@... | 07/08/09
RE: IT professionals will not drop Windows XP quietly (if ever) timbury | 07/07/09
Did you answer the poll questions? Mark W. KaelinTechrepublic Moderator | 07/08/09
Main reason anonymuos | 07/11/09
Amazed at the Silly Comments! mdbrimberry@... | 07/17/09
Criteria for change husserl@... | 07/18/09
You make your own point tonycopp@... | 07/18/09
You make your own point tonycopp@... | 07/18/09
CEO's prefer stable, productive systems gorman.mi@... | 07/18/09
Most will be off of XP within 2-3 years ejhonda | 08/11/09
Will you Own the Risk of Up?grade tonycopp@... | 08/20/09
tendency - stay with the familiar xambassador | 10/08/09
Works for me dberkey@... | 10/22/09

What do you think?

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Recent Entries

TR on Twitter

Archives

TechRepublic Blogs



500 Things Every Technology Professional Needs to Know
Did you know Microsoft's RegClean does not work with XP but you can use shareware to clean your registry? Did you know most wireless access points don't have encryption enabled by default? Did you know there are 500 tidbits of information contained in TechRepublic's 500 Things Every Technology Professional Needs to Know that will help you become a successful IT professional.
Buy Now
Administrator's Guide to TCP/IP, Second Edition
Maintain your critical TCP/IP system and ensure reliable, safe remote access. Get the expert advice and solutions to handle Windows networking, Cisco routing, documentation, and troubleshooting.
Buy Now

SmartPlanet

Click Here