TechRepublic : A ZDNet Tech Community

The Right Tool for the Job?

Host: Bill Detwiler
Contact

The Job

Within the open source — and especially the Linux — community, there are basically two options for replacing Microsoft Outlook: Kontact and Evolution. As you know, Outlook is an all-in-one e-mail, calendar, task, and contact application that also publishes information. In a corporate environment (especially a large corporate environment), most companies use an Exchange server to handle mail. If you are an employee in such an environment, and you want to adopt a Linux desktop you will be very limited in what you can do with an Exchange server. Will either Kontact or Evolution fit into your environment? Let’s find out.

The Tool

Evolution

Evolution was started by the manic-brainiac known as Miguel di Icaza. His goal was to finally have an all-in-one that would make businesses give Linux on the desktop a serious look. He achieved his goal. Evolution comes packed with all the features you would expect in such a tool: Email, Calendar, Contact management, Tasks and Todo lists, Exchange support. Evolutions’ standards support includes: IMAP, POP, SMTP and Authenticated SMTP, as well as Microsoft Exchange 2000 and 2003. And now that Exchange is “owned” by Novell it is enjoying GroupWise support (currently in beta.) Evolution also enjoys S/MIME support as well as Palm device support.

The Right Tool for the Job?

Evolution, the relief of administrators everywhere, acts and behaves very similarly to Outlook. So users will not suffer from much (if any) learning curve. The UI is intuitive and user-friendly. To the average user they probably wouldn’t even notice if you exchanged their Outlook with Evolution. To the power user, well, that might be another story. One of my biggest beefs with Evolution, for some time now, has been the problem with PDA support. The gpilotd daemon has been nothing but flaky for the last several years. But that small price to pay does not detract from the power of Evolution. If you are looking for a single application to replace Outlook you need look no further than Evolution. It is as feature rich, easy to use, and (in my experience) far more reliable than Outlook.

Of course using Evolution to replace Outlook does come with this warning: Use with Exchange is not seamless. You may sometimes find that events aren’t shared or invitations aren’t received. This is to be expected with any software attempting to communicate with anything created by Microsoft. Expect a little flakiness now and again and you will not be upset.

View my screenshot gallery of Evolution.

Print/View all Posts Comments on this blog

Glad there's some alternatives to Outlook Dr Dij | 02/20/08
Why COPY Outlook then? The Listed 'G MAN' | 02/20/08
I think the article mentioned it Neon Samurai | 02/20/08
So, The Question Begs Itself rickk@... | 02/26/08
Differences istari2ve2002@... | 02/26/08
Excellent point blarman | 02/26/08
Outlook May Be More Expensive on Exchange 2008 Lazarus439 | 02/26/08
Under the hood it's better? maybejunk01@... | 02/26/08
Touch? istari2ve2002@... | 02/28/08
Good Point TheGooch1 | 02/26/08
I thought his point cancelled itself out Neon Samurai | 02/26/08
Not What I'm Saying at All rickk@... | 02/27/08
You did catch me on a bad day but your comment opening line... Neon Samurai | 02/27/08
"If one isn't going the open source route" Neon Samurai | 02/26/08
Simple Answers rickk@... | 02/27/08
touche.. :) Neon Samurai | 02/27/08
Copy? dm@... | 02/26/08
here Neon Samurai | 02/26/08
Of Course Neon Samurai rickk@... | 02/27/08
I meant simply to clarify the difference between common UI elements .. Neon Samurai | 02/27/08
boo.. what distro and release version? doug@... | 03/02/08
eGroupware is having issues.. boo again Neon Samurai | 03/02/08
I'm sure glad you guys posted here recently seanferd | 03/02/08
review of email client erwin.hasanuddin@... | 11/21/08
typo; "Exchange owned by Novell" Neon Samurai | 02/20/08
You didn't hear? Palmetto | 02/20/08
ha.. that made me giggle Neon Samurai | 02/20/08
Well, as a thought The Scummy One | 02/20/08
a fair interpretation Neon Samurai | 02/20/08
oop jlwallen@... | 02/20/08
PalmOS issues due to USB? Neon Samurai | 02/20/08
If there was a way? frank.schafer@... | 02/26/08
HAL also tries to use a static mount possition for USB Neon Samurai | 02/26/08
Are You Listening to Your Own Words? rickk@... | 02/27/08
I never said it was perfect, just better suited to my needs Neon Samurai | 02/27/08
It would depend Jaqui | 02/20/08
just took another look at evolution Jaqui | 02/21/08
and "T-bird"? (makes 3) dawgit | 02/21/08
not quite though Jaqui | 02/21/08
I hear they're comming though... dawgit | 02/21/08
yes it would.. Jaqui | 02/21/08
Agreed, mostly anyway B-) dawgit | 02/21/08
Email wise yes Spiritusindomit@... | 02/26/08
Email unwise james_roman@... | 02/26/08
because Outlook doesn't support standard internet calendars). TheGooch1 | 02/26/08
Outlook is best for individuals, w/o Exchange shumisha@... | 02/27/08
Not everyone..... FXEF | 02/28/08
Large Corporate Environment - not just email vicki_711 | 02/26/08
RE: Evolution: The Right Tool for the Job? stomfi@... | 02/26/08
Typical Linux Nerd Microsoft Bashing Again tony@... | 02/26/08
My my, aren't we teeming with insecurity? loss4words | 02/26/08
Don't bother, l4w bbbaldie_z | 02/26/08
and. . . onthego | 02/26/08
Same experience loss4words | 02/28/08
i shan't loss4words | 02/28/08
Actually, I agree that was a minor jab at Microsoft, for no reason. gmmoon@... | 02/26/08
Does loss4words | 02/28/08
Works on my Linux box... FXEF | 02/26/08
Willing to accept some flakyness??? dvecchioni@... | 03/06/08
RE: Evolution: The Right Tool for the Job? riverdusty@... | 02/26/08
Heard, but not a replacement shumisha@... | 02/26/08
The problem is not and has never been replacing outlook. Spiritusindomit@... | 02/26/08
To say it's superior is like comparing apples to oranges craiglarry@... | 02/26/08
Well Supported Statement TheGooch1 | 02/26/08
Exchange is the key jred | 02/26/08
Replacing Exchange pdf6161 | 02/26/08
RE: Evolution: The Right Tool for the Job? ppzelek@... | 02/26/08
Evolution - Not a good tool for the job TheGooch1 | 02/26/08
And what about integration?? sml@... | 02/26/08
What about Thunderbird? jozhall@... | 02/26/08
Thunderbird is a great email client Neon Samurai | 02/26/08
Don't Waste Your Time TheGooch1 | 03/05/08
I'm sticking to Thunderbird and Korganizer for the moment Neon Samurai | 03/05/08
Works for me. dawgit | 02/26/08
What about Single Sign-on? And archiving? dan.stalker@... | 02/26/08
My Blackberry keeps me from leaving Outlook g0dFather | 02/26/08
Suggestions, please!? GettReal | 02/26/08
What....? dawgit | 02/26/08
Blackberry works with Lotus Notes sml@... | 02/27/08
For me it was PalmOS that kept my PIM info in Outlook Neon Samurai | 02/27/08
Just the facts Ma'am! kerry.millen@... | 02/26/08
Missing the point.... FXEF | 02/26/08
Objective kerry.millen@... | 02/27/08
RE: Evolution: The Right Tool for the Job? gpfear@... | 02/26/08
How do you run evolution on KDE? doug@... | 02/26/08
will run under KDE FXEF | 02/26/08
I don't think Evolution runs under KDE doug@... | 02/27/08
evolution was developed for GNOME gfearnow1@... | 02/27/08
Linux is not a single OS though Neon Samurai | 02/27/08
Evolution didn't seem to like KDE doug@... | 02/29/08
boo.. what distro and release version? Neon Samurai | 02/29/08
Importing Outlook data in Evolution Alganon | 02/26/08
Receiving meeting requests from Outlook users ricardoc@... | 02/27/08
RE: Evolution: The Right Tool for the Job? albert.jeremie@... | 02/27/08
No, evolution uses IMAP doug@... | 03/03/08
agreed loss4words | 03/04/08
Get Hosted Exchange If You Are Cheap TheGooch1 | 03/05/08
Truly comparing apples with rutabagas... awgiedawgie | 03/04/09
Broad Generalizations Answerfactory | 03/13/09

What do you think?

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Recent Entries

TR on Twitter

Top Rated

    Archives

    TechRepublic Blogs



    500 Things Every Technology Professional Needs to Know
    Did you know Microsoft's RegClean does not work with XP but you can use shareware to clean your registry? Did you know most wireless access points don't have encryption enabled by default? Did you know there are 500 tidbits of information contained in TechRepublic's 500 Things Every Technology Professional Needs to Know that will help you become a successful IT professional.
    Buy Now
    Quick Reference: Linux Commands
    Reduce stress and speed up resolutions with the easiest command references right at your fingertips. You'll receive a PDF file covering Linux, packed with the most common commands you'll need and use daily.
    Buy Now

    SmartPlanet

    Click Here