TechRepublic : A ZDNet Tech Community

Linux and Open Source

Host: Jack Wallen
Contact

In his quest to find the simplest Linux distribution, Jack Wallen makes a stop at PCLinuxOS and may have found the holy grail of simple operating systems. Read Jack’s take on PCLinuxOS and decide for yourself if PCLinuxOS is your “go-to” Linux distribution.

——————————————————————————————————

The slogan for PCLinuxOS is “Radically Simple” and, as far as I can tell, it might be one of the most fitting operating system slogans I have seen. But does it apply across the board? From start to finish? I decided it had been too long since I had tried this distribution so I went about giving it a go. I have to say I was certainly impressed.

With some distributions, along with the claim of being the easiest, comes the stigma of being overly simple, or “dumbed down.” Some of these distributions come with “helpful” widgets and graphics that look as if they were targeting an elementary school class. Not PCLinuxOS. PCLinuxOS retains a professional look and feel while remaining one of the easiest to use Linux distributions available. Let’s take a look at what PCLinuxOS offers.

Based upon…
PCLinuxOS is based upon Mandriva and uses the Mandriva control center and Draklive installer. Along with Mandriva technology, PCLinuxOS is bolstered by patches from OpenSuSE, Gentoo, Fedora, Ubuntu, and Debian. Let’s think about this one. You have available a distribution that benefits from all of the other outstanding distributions. So from the very beginning PCLinuxOS holds much promise.

On top of a strong foundation PCLinuxOS offers KDE 3.5.6 which is one of the more stable and user-friendly of the larger desktop environments.

But it’s not what’s installed that makes PCLinuxOS so “radically simple.” No. What makes PCLinuxOS so radically simple is how it keeps the user from having to do tasks they aren’t used to doing. Let’s take a look.

Installation
I tested the PCLinuxOS installation on a number of machines (including a laptop). Each machine was comprised of varied hardware and none of the machines were similar. Everything from antiquated video to newly released wireless cards were a part of the equation, and not once did PCLinuxOS falter. The distribution found, and used, everything. Even with the laptop, where I have found some Live CDs to work fine only to have the fully-installed distribution flake out, PCLinuxOS was a hit. The only improvement I could offer would be the inclusion of WICD for wireless connectivity.

Now one possible “gotcha” was that, during the installation, PCLinuxOS allows you to have the root user without a password. I found this a little off putting because (1) Does this mean there will be no root password and “sudo” will be used or (2) Does this mean the root user uses no password? If it’s the former I can live with that (because I am a Ubuntu user and am used to sudo). If it is the latter - I can not live with that because that would make for one very unsafe system.

Usage
As I said before, KDE 3.5.6 is installed, so usage is very simple. But PCLinuxOS goes well beyond that. It seems all of their tools were selected for simplicity of use. From the Synaptic package installation system to the SuperKaramba widget system (we have to keep up with OS X after all) every package installed is not only simple to use, but an outstanding addition to any Linux installation.

Bells and whistles
The default desktop is very clean looking. Fortunately PCLinuxOS is shying away (currently) from KDE 4 and KDE 3.5.6 can be (and is, out of the box) set up so that the user is instantly familiar with every aspect of the desktop. Mostly the KDE 3.5.6 desktop isn’t terribly flashy. About the only added flash is the aforementioned SuperKaramba. SK adds widgets (of various types) to the desktop. Most of the widgets available for SK are monitor-type widgets which, to be honest, aren’t terribly useful to the end user. But there are multimedia controller widgets, dock widgets, application controller widgets (the OpenOffice bar is one of my favs), and calendar widgets. So the desktop can be changed from new-user to power-user pretty quickly.

So Who is PCLinuxOS For?
PCLinuxOS might be one of those distributions that can easily be for everyone. From the new user who has never touched Linux before to the guru, anyone would be hard-pressed to find something to seriously complain about with this distribution.

What is your "go-to" Linux distribution?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Final thoughts
What impressed me the most about PCLinuxOS is its lack of pretension. The creators of PCLinuxOS know their audience is a wide cross section and know how to present their wares to that audience without being insulting or coming across as “better than the rest.” PCLinuxOS is a simple-to-use operating system that makes the user forget that it’s there. And isn’t that the whole point of an operating system - to bridge the gap between the user and the hardware and make the work seamless? Well that’s exactly what PCLinuxOS does best: Seamless.

I highly recommend this distribution to pretty much anyone. If you have people you’re hoping to win over to Linux this might be your go-to OS. If you have hardware that other distributions don’t seem to like, again, this might be your OS. Give PCLinuxOS a try. It really is “radically simple.”

Jack Wallen was a key player in the introduction of Linux to the original Techrepublic. Beginning with Red Hat 4.2 and a mighty soap box, Jack had found his escape from Windows. It was around Red Hat 6.0 that Jack landed in the hallowed halls of Techrepublic. Read his full bio and profile.

Print/View all Posts Comments on this blog

My Go-To OS btidwell | 07/28/08
Lots of Spinoofs Too phillfri | 07/29/08
A BIG Double Thumbs Up mckinnej | 07/31/08
RE: PCLinuxOS: Definitely The Scummy One | 07/28/08
Definately alxcsby@... | 07/28/08
LOL -- and changed :D The Scummy One | 07/28/08
PC Linux OS JustinF | 07/28/08
Agreed PCLOS is a desktop OS w2ktechman | 07/28/08
PCLOS as a Server travisn000@... | 07/29/08
Definitely not for a server! mckenna.terry@... | 08/04/08
PCLinuxOS is definitely the easiest to use yschoo1@... | 07/29/08
Chinese Language Betelgeuse58 | 07/30/08
Ill give it a look matthew.balthrop@... | 03/13/09
Don't forget Linux Mint Doug Vitale | 07/29/08
There are a number of "as friendly" distros as PCLinuxOS Neon Samurai | 07/31/08
RE: PCLinuxOS: Definately webwalker_z | 07/29/08
Not Sure ... dondidly@... | 07/29/08
Xub should do nicely on that humble rig Neon Samurai | 07/31/08
Same as webwalker_z shevloff | 07/29/08
..wireless travisn000@... | 07/29/08
mini me lastchip | 07/31/08
My experience with PCLOS and wireless...& a suggestion: Betelgeuse58 | 07/30/08
Had the same problem when I tried to install it on my computer rhomp2002@... | 07/31/08
doing similar here Neon Samurai | 07/31/08
Yes, I like it. lastchip | 07/29/08
Yup -- I had to reinstall The Scummy One | 07/29/08
old hardware issues / no password root user option comments Jaqui | 07/29/08
...256 mb ram travisn000@... | 07/29/08
Gnome edition requires Root password JustinF | 07/29/08
PCLinuxOS has a MiniMe version clellaja@... | 07/30/08
oops Jaqui | 07/30/08
Mandriva uses root password, or it does now anyhow Neon Samurai | 07/31/08
yup, but the Others don't play well with me | 08/01/08
ick.. yeah, that's no good Neon Samurai | 08/01/08
PCLOS 2007 & Passwords....... Betelgeuse58 | 08/01/08
simple, with a bit of thought Jaqui | 08/02/08
Types of users Betelgeuse58 | 08/02/08
RE: PCLinuxOS: Definately BobK Linux Noob | 07/29/08
PCLinuxOS fan here. danielh_7777@... | 07/30/08
RE: PCLinuxOS: Definately i1-14174 | 07/31/08
RE: PCLinuxOS: Definately walrus@... | 07/31/08
There are some other "game" distros you may want to test Neon Samurai | 07/31/08
Was this it? Dumphrey | 08/01/08
Linux Gamers Live DVD feral@... | 08/02/08
that was the one Neon Samurai | 08/04/08
RE: PCLinuxOS: Definately dave@... | 07/31/08
except for wireless issues alan.schmeelk@... | 07/31/08
My PCLinuxOS penguinibros@... | 07/31/08
PCLinuxOS Rocks! dpresley_50201@... | 03/11/09
The only problem I've had with it NickNielsen | 03/12/09
interesting w2ktechman | 03/12/09
Supergrup Neon Samurai | 03/13/09
Keep it safe and backed up! seanferd | 03/13/09
say what? Neon Samurai | 03/13/09
Maybe I need to backtrack seanferd | 03/13/09
Sorry, you can have your brain back The Scummy One | 03/13/09
no worries.. thought you may have read something I missed Neon Samurai | 03/14/09
OK | thanks | wow | duh seanferd | 03/14/09
Cheers, it's a training requirnment for my needs Neon Samurai | 03/15/09
Well, I was kind of in a hurry NickNielsen | 03/13/09
I can relate. BT would have been my first grab. Neon Samurai | 03/13/09

What do you think?

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Recent Entries

TR on Twitter

Archives

TechRepublic Blogs



IT Help Desk Survival Guide, Third Edition
TechRepublic's IT Help Desk Survival Guide, Third Edition provides tools and recommendations to help you better manage help desk services, improve end-user support, troubleshoot frustrating hardware issues, identify quick fixes to vexing Windows problems, and help users make the most of Microsoft Office 2003.
Buy Now
Quick Reference: Linux Commands
Reduce stress and speed up resolutions with the easiest command references right at your fingertips. You'll receive a PDF file covering Linux, packed with the most common commands you'll need and use daily.
Buy Now

SmartPlanet

Click Here