TechRepublic : A ZDNet Tech Community

TR Dojo

by Bill Detwiler, Head Technology Editor
Contact

Poll: Should the US Government block sites/regulate Internet traffic during times of crisis?

Yesterday, I published a piece on a US Government Accountability Office (GAO) report (GAO-10-8) that suggests a serious influenza pandemic could result in a massive spike in Internet traffic and that the US government may need to step in and act as an Internet traffic cop; limiting people’s bandwidth or blocking bandwidth-intensive sites altogether.

A vigorous debate over the practicality, effectiveness, and legality of this issue in the post’s discussion thread. So, I though putting up a poll that allows people to quickly vote on the issue made sense. Let me know what you think.

Should the US government block high-bandwidth sites or manage Internet traffic to prevent congestion during times of crisis?

Loading ... Loading ...

Bill DetwilerBill Detwiler is Head Technology Editor of TechRepublic. Previously, he worked as a Support Tech and IT Manager in the social research and energy industries. Read his full bio and profile. You can also follow him on Twitter.

Print/View all Posts Comments on this blog

Absolutely not under any circumstances... Jeff7181@... | 10/29/09
Internet restriction cjoyce | 10/30/09
In a perfect world ..... aandruli@... | 10/30/09
RE: Internet restriction Jeff7181@... | 11/01/09
...?? ckanow@... | 11/03/09
Communist - Facist , no difference to the people at all -nt Deadly Ernest | 11/03/09
There is important difference jkameleon@... | 11/03/09
Funny, every facist and socialist/ communist government Deadly Ernest | 11/04/09
Fascism and communism are similar in many ways because... jkameleon@... | 11/04/09
The only difference is in the bookkeeping JohnMcGrew@... | 11/05/09
Agreed david@... | 11/02/09
The government needs to leave things alone. tenebrulus | 11/02/09
Allow gov't control in emergencies and you'll guarantee emergecies... john.parker@... | 11/02/09
they should not - but i am sure they will if they want to gbb0330@... | 11/03/09
Should the Internet block governmental interference? trud | 10/29/09
"move to China boxfiddler | 10/29/09
Re-Education trud | 10/29/09
Now let's finish that sentence, properly. Deadly Ernest | 10/29/09
Nudge Nudge trud | 10/29/09
You're on someone's list now JackOfAllTech | 10/29/09
Shoot, I've been on the CIA, FBI, DEA, RCMP, and ASIO lists Deadly Ernest | 10/29/09
Personal opnion aside, Uncle Sam has more guns SilverBullet | 10/30/09
Are you sure about that? TonytheTiger | 10/30/09
They have the big ones SilverBullet | 10/30/09
There ain't enought of those NickNielsen | 10/30/09
Same question TonytheTiger | 11/02/09
Why should they worry? NickNielsen | 10/29/09
As well they should trud | 10/29/09
Where there is a major disaster and many of the Deadly Ernest | 10/29/09
And we are trud | 10/29/09
But when they fly, it's a case of swine flew. Seriously, the Deadly Ernest | 10/29/09
When Swine Fly trud | 10/29/09
I've seen Swine Fly - I was in Canberra the day that GWB Deadly Ernest | 10/29/09
They close interstates, don't they? Palmetto | 10/30/09
using internets causes death? bboyd@... | 10/30/09
Highways have been closed due to excessive traffic. Palmetto | 10/30/09
As per the request, elsewhere, I'll respond to this too. Deadly Ernest | 10/31/09
Okay, I see where you're coming from. Palmetto | 10/31/09
I'll try to be quick and respond to some of this without Deadly Ernest | 10/31/09
That's to stop the germs moving, and it does nothing to Deadly Ernest | 10/30/09
Germs? Where did that come from? Palmetto | 10/30/09
The blocks on the interstates during a panepidemic are Deadly Ernest | 10/30/09
I'm still not with you. Palmetto | 10/31/09
I've addressed the response to the posts in this sub thread Deadly Ernest | 10/31/09
RE: They close interstates, don't they? Jeff7181@... | 11/01/09
Neither is using the Internet. Palmetto | 11/04/09
Generally speaking... jkameleon@... | 10/30/09
"Never let a serious crisis go to waste" JohnMcGrew@... | 10/30/09
Disaster Capitalism Slang1 | 11/02/09
That was funny! JohnMcGrew@... | 11/03/09
I Agree TheAlcatrazKid | 11/03/09
The do this to all other media sources The 'G-Man.' | 10/30/09
Give the Feds an excuse to grab more power in an "emergency"... mmoran@... | 10/30/09
RE: Poll: Should the US Government block sites/regulate Internet traffic du mike@... | 10/30/09
RE: Poll: Should the US Government block sites/regulate Internet traffic during times of crisis? wizard57m@... | 11/01/09
Crash prevention ultimitloozer@... | 11/02/09
I'd be surprised if they don't have a 'doctors only' site - nt Deadly Ernest | 11/03/09
RE: Poll: Should the US Government block sites/regulate Internet traffic during times of crisis? tcobb@... | 11/02/09
RE: Poll: Should the US Government block sites/regulate Internet traffic during times of crisis? glennanorris@... | 11/02/09
RE: Poll: Should the US Government block sites/regulate Internet traffic during times of crisis? mauited2004@... | 11/02/09
RE: Poll: Should the US Government block sites/regulate Internet traffic du glorious@... | 11/02/09
RE: Poll: Should the US Government block sites/regulate Internet traffic during times of crisis? glorious@... | 11/02/09
Road paths are a fixed structure rhisiart22@... | 11/02/09
RE: Poll: Should the US Government block sites/regulate Internet traffic during times of crisis? hypnowist | 11/03/09

What do you think?

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Recent Entries

TR on Twitter

Archives

TechRepublic Blogs



IT Help Desk Survival Guide, Third Edition
TechRepublic's IT Help Desk Survival Guide, Third Edition provides tools and recommendations to help you better manage help desk services, improve end-user support, troubleshoot frustrating hardware issues, identify quick fixes to vexing Windows problems, and help users make the most of Microsoft Office 2003.
Buy Now
500 Things Every Technology Professional Needs to Know
Did you know Microsoft's RegClean does not work with XP but you can use shareware to clean your registry? Did you know most wireless access points don't have encryption enabled by default? Did you know there are 500 tidbits of information contained in TechRepublic's 500 Things Every Technology Professional Needs to Know that will help you become a successful IT professional.
Buy Now

SmartPlanet

Click Here