TechRepublic : A ZDNet Tech Community

Career Management

by Toni Bowers, Head Blogs Editor
Contact

City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords

Officials in the city of Bozeman, Montana are asking job applicants to turn over their user names and passwords to social networking sites like Facebook as part of their background checks.

——————————————————————————————————————-

Remember last week when you thought the worst of your job-hunting worries was answering the dreaded Where do you see yourself in five years question? Well, set aside that beef because there’s a new interviewing element in town (well, in one town at least), and it’s ugly.

A town once called the “All-America City,” Bozeman, Montana, has taken an interesting tack when it comes to background checks on job candidates. According to cbsnews.com:

The Rocky Mountain city instructs all job applicants to divulge their usernames and passwords for “any Internet-based chat rooms, social clubs or forums, to include, but not limited to: Facebook, Google, Yahoo, YouTube.com, MySpace, etc.” Bozeman city officials say that this is just a component of a thorough background check.

Chuck Winn, Bozeman’s assistant city manager, was quoted as saying,

“Shame on us if there was information out there available about a person who applied for a job who was a child molester or had some sort of information out there on the Internet that kind of showed those propensities and we didn’t look for it, we didn’t ask, and we hired that person. In many ways we would have let the public down.”

Though the handing over of such personal and confidential information is not required, the Bozeman group says that if you claim something on your application and they later find out you lied, you will be fired.

The legal community weighs in

Kevin Bankston, an attorney, said, “Essentially they’re conditioning your application for employment on your waiving your First Amendment rights … and risking the security of your information by requiring you to share your password with them… Where does it stop? How about a photocopy of your diary?”

Wow. Remind me never to apply for a job in Bozeman. What do you guys think of this turn of events, and will it catch on elsewhere?

Toni BowersToni Bowers is the Head Blogs Editor of TechRepublic. She has been in the publishing industry for 20 years, with concentration in IT-related topics. She has edited newsletters, books, and web sites pertaining to software, IT career, and IT management issues.

Print/View all Posts Comments on this blog

Draconian at Best dlane@... | 06/19/09
From Todays News -City stops asking Darryl~ | 06/20/09
Only if you give me the Mayor's password to share with facebook. macphersonr@... | 06/22/09
Freedom of Information Act Arsynic | 06/23/09
What morons they have in this town paul.doherty@... | 06/23/09
Obviously, TonytheTiger | 06/23/09
So what's ipessoa | 06/23/09
I haven't seen anything else Darryl~ | 06/23/09
Simple request, simple answer Kris.J | 06/23/09
And then, if you do have any of these accounts, you are seen as a liar Wick Tech | 06/26/09
I wouldn't answer it at all Yam Digger | 07/08/09
Current Employees MPG187 | 07/09/09
Hire people based on actual ability? NickNielsen | 07/10/09
*snickers* EOM Bad Boys Drive Audi | 07/10/09
EXACTLY! MPG187 | 07/13/09
And people submit calmly to a urine test. OnTheRopes | 06/20/09
That's what happens santeewelding | 06/20/09
Yeah, but Datacommguy | 06/22/09
As long as they... TonytheTiger | 06/22/09
Fair is Fair W.E. | 06/22/09
Exactly who do you want tested? Palmetto | 06/24/09
Actually - Not so much bratwizard@... | 06/26/09
RE: Yeah, but (Datacommguy) ITCompGuy | 06/23/09
Point Taken Datacommguy | 06/24/09
Agreed Palmetto | 06/24/09
Freedom of Expression and Rebuttal bratwizard@... | 06/26/09
But But But gmwwc@... | 07/26/09
Several differences. Palmetto | 06/24/09
dream on.. Shellbot | 06/22/09
I would just walk away from the job v.farrell@... | 06/23/09
Are we really surprised???? lodestone | 06/22/09
Surprised? No. Appalled? You betcha! rileystrehlow@... | 06/23/09
REVERSED lodestone | 06/24/09
Perfect example of how government works Ed.Carden@... | 06/22/09
The other thing... TonytheTiger | 06/23/09
Walk around naked ? Peon | 06/23/09
Great analogy v.farrell@... | 06/23/09
Might not be right...but.... ITCompGuy | 06/23/09
Is this a joke? mrdt | 06/23/09
Is this a joke? sparky52@... | 06/24/09
very true, and this new higher paying job may be all you need Deadly Ernest | 06/24/09
ya MPG187 | 06/25/09
Tell me, do the city workers where mid brown or Deadly Ernest | 06/19/09
Both, probably. seanferd | 06/19/09
Warnings of "on-line presence" KSoniat | 06/19/09
Facebook versus LinkedIn TiggerTwo | 06/19/09
I do the same thing KSoniat | 06/19/09
triathlons and preposterous john.a.wills@... | 06/19/09
Geesh KSoniat | 06/19/09
Maybe he's achieved his dream... NickNielsen | 06/19/09
re: Maybe he's achieved his dream... steven.peonio@... | 06/23/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and password arnie7 | 06/19/09
turn over Facebook user names and password Firedrake | 06/23/09
This would have been an easy bet to win NotSoChiGuy | 06/19/09
Also, in a couple of years, seanferd | 06/19/09
B-I-N-G-O!!! NotSoChiGuy | 06/22/09
LOL seanferd | 06/22/09
Just to apply for a job? Darryl~ | 06/19/09
I wonder how they react if, when asked for the information, you Deadly Ernest | 06/19/09
Or you could ask Darryl~ | 06/19/09
Wow -- really? This is a sad state of affairs The Scummy One | 06/19/09
Incredible! bunkyaz | 06/19/09
I have a hard time beleiving The Scummy One | 06/19/09
Re: City wants to own potential employees lock, stock and barrel SKDTech | 06/19/09
I would need two pages Wild Card | 06/19/09
I can understand asking for User Names library assistant | 06/19/09
Rediculous!!!!! sidekick | 06/19/09
Ha! Right! seanferd | 06/19/09
If read carefully... kkopp | 06/23/09
There is that aspect as well. seanferd | 06/23/09
Wow...what morons. robo_dev | 06/19/09
:0 NickNielsen | 06/19/09
Chevy!? Slvrknght | 06/22/09
When they log in with your password, have them arrested robo_dev | 06/19/09
Unfortunately when it comes to government SKDTech | 06/19/09
Here it is seanferd | 06/19/09
Ummm... Let me think about that... H3!! NO!! cmiller5400 | 06/19/09
Just Say NO! LocoLobo | 06/19/09
I simply would never work for the city jmgarvin | 06/19/09
Well, it's one thing to lambaste them here... MGP2 | 06/19/09
Send a Letter to Bozeman Officials bratwizard@... | 06/26/09
Why? NickNielsen | 06/19/09
Well, to an extent... MGP2 | 06/19/09
Maybe NickNielsen | 06/19/09
How? boxfiddler | 06/19/09
Go back further Master Of Reality | 06/22/09
Before my time NickNielsen | 06/22/09
Party? TonytheTiger | 06/22/09
In the moment boxfiddler | 06/19/09
Montana Human Rights Law BFilmFan | 06/19/09
Then do a freakin' search, Bozeman! seanferd | 06/19/09
Haha! Read this bit. seanferd | 06/20/09
Not very intelligent, are they? melias@... | 06/22/09
No. seanferd | 06/22/09
ROFL -- they would explore that option The Scummy One | 06/23/09
What about non-electronic publishing? Palmetto | 06/24/09
Someone there's been drinking bad "boze." deepsand | 06/20/09
Isn't it always that way? seanferd | 06/22/09
Each believes that he's the exception, a "benign" despot. deepsand | 06/23/09
Ah, yes. seanferd | 06/23/09
The frightening part is ... deepsand | 06/24/09
What it tells me TonytheTiger | 06/20/09
Have some with it BFilmFan | 06/21/09
Ferengi Rule of Acquisition no. 112 deepsand | 06/21/09
Don't give them anything. Dr_Zinj | 06/22/09
And maybe that is exactly The Scummy One | 06/22/09
Facebook terms of Service: swelker@... | 06/22/09
Hate to say it... QA-usimodo | 06/22/09
City wants applicants to turn over . . . Systems Guy | 06/22/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords henrik.sorensen@... | 06/22/09
Utterly ridiculous. Histrion2 | 06/22/09
I must be boring! george.flecknell@... | 06/22/09
don't be such a Shellbot | 06/22/09
Cool Down granbot royala@... | 06/23/09
As a Granny The Scummy One | 06/23/09
Problem with bandwidth/time wasting jdclyde | 06/23/09
i'm hardly stressed about it Shellbot | 06/23/09
Then how should we group you :0 The Scummy One | 06/23/09
For the record... george.flecknell@... | 06/24/09
cool, thanks for the clarification Shellbot | 06/24/09
...and modest too. george.flecknell@... | 06/24/09
thanks Shellbot | 06/24/09
You can't be serious... Darryl~ | 06/24/09
Enlightenment please Palmetto | 06/24/09
Why engage someone so out of touch with reality? jdclyde | 06/24/09
:) Shellbot | 06/24/09
Whilst.... george.flecknell@... | 06/25/09
Actually.... george.flecknell@... | 06/25/09
Here's a waste of time Bad Boys Drive Audi | 06/27/09
hey Royal Shellbot | 06/24/09
Three problems Palmetto | 06/24/09
So...block facebook on the comnpany systems The 'G-Man.' | 06/23/09
Let him cry jdclyde | 06/23/09
re: I must be... steven.peonio@... | 06/23/09
A point about Firewalls and Face/space jdclyde | 06/23/09
re: a point... steven.peonio@... | 06/23/09
game points ... or rob mekel | 06/24/09
If you say so, Steve jdclyde | 06/24/09
re: if you say so.. steven.peonio@... | 06/28/09
Please tell me Steven jdclyde | 06/30/09
Clock watchers are the bane of all. deepsand | 06/30/09
I might suggest TonytheTiger | 06/24/09
"if people have a facebook account ... just not give them a job." Palmetto | 06/24/09
Are You Serious? Bad Boys Drive Audi | 06/27/09
Not hiring good workers MPG187 | 06/28/09
WELL! george.flecknell@... | 06/29/09
Proof, please, that commission of an illegal act ... deepsand | 06/29/09
Putatively illegal act santeewelding | 06/29/09
We've all been badly informed. deepsand | 06/29/09
Fork off George. boxfiddler | 06/29/09
My dear santeewelding | 06/29/09
boxfiddler | 06/29/09
deepsand | 06/29/09
Titivate, my man santeewelding | 06/29/09
Concessions to civilian conventions are oft times useful. deepsand | 06/29/09
Propogangda MPG187 | 06/30/09
Use vs. Abuse MPG187 | 06/30/09
Too cheap and lazy to perform a proper check harrylal | 06/22/09
You sheep made this bed. bblackmoor@... | 06/22/09
Also, we'd like your sexual history, Palmetto | 06/22/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords desirawson@... | 06/22/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords Bad Boys Drive Audi | 06/22/09
Add the Brooksville, FL underwear police to the Bozeman, MT silliness..! J-R-Doe | 06/22/09
Sharing Password - Against TOS? gardnea@... | 06/22/09
What About Privacy? GingerLassy | 06/22/09
Invasion of Privacy MPG187 | 06/22/09
Stick it ken.dally@... | 06/22/09
Gosh! What a gold mine... mikifinaz1@... | 06/22/09
Let me guess what's the next version makkh@... | 06/22/09
Requirement dropped! :D seanferd | 06/23/09
However The 'G-Man.' | 06/23/09
I'll bet you are right, sir. (nt) seanferd | 06/23/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords m@... | 06/23/09
That town aint right! stuart@... | 06/23/09
Crime will go up MPG187 | 06/25/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords bobg@... | 06/23/09
This is a violation of the Terms of Use of about any Social Networking site andrewd8@... | 06/23/09
Ya it is a violation MPG187 | 06/25/09
It's violation of privacy not only mine but others too. Mr.Newman | 06/23/09
Good for the Goose, Good for the Gander gary.mack@... | 06/23/09
Why not just set up "reeducation camps" in Bozeman. rtillotson@... | 06/23/09
Bozeman request for Username/Password rlsnyder@... | 06/23/09
Shhhhhh! DaemonSlayer | 06/23/09
Next Step The Scummy One | 06/23/09
Already do that... DaemonSlayer | 06/23/09
what was meant was The Scummy One | 06/23/09
Please step to the side zclayton2 | 06/23/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords khazeltine@... | 06/23/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords DaveCurlee | 06/23/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords Derek Schauland | 06/23/09
Thats laughable AV . | 06/23/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords cwizshyam@... | 06/23/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords dkbjee64@... | 06/24/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords buket3@... | 06/25/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords codeisme@... | 06/25/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords bratwizard@... | 06/26/09
easier to just ask them if they know what a rimjob is and tell Deadly Ernest | 07/08/09
They can Kiss My Ass bratwizard@... | 06/26/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords spencercountyman | 07/08/09
I disagree... Bad Boys Drive Audi | 07/09/09
Just Consent to 24/7 wiretapping of your phones and accounts smartaffair@... | 07/17/09
RE: City wants job applicants to turn over Facebook user names and passwords simon@... | 07/19/09

What do you think?

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Recent Entries

TR on Twitter

Archives

TechRepublic Blogs



500 Things Every Technology Professional Needs to Know
Did you know Microsoft's RegClean does not work with XP but you can use shareware to clean your registry? Did you know most wireless access points don't have encryption enabled by default? Did you know there are 500 tidbits of information contained in TechRepublic's 500 Things Every Technology Professional Needs to Know that will help you become a successful IT professional.
Buy Now
IT Professional's Guide to Policies and Procedures, Third Ed
Whether you're creating policies for management, training, personnel, support, privacy, Internet/e-mail usage, security, or inventory, you'll meet the needs of your entire enterprise with this one download!
Buy Now

SmartPlanet

Click Here