TechRepublic : A ZDNet Tech Community

Career Management

by Toni Bowers, Head Blogs Editor
Contact

People have many reasons to pursue a job that is deemed by others to be “below their station.” How do you convince a potential employer to give you a chance?

——————————————————————————————————————-

Of all the reasons to be rejected for a job, being told you’re “overqualified” really sucks. There are many reasons someone might look for a position that is “under the station” of what he normally would do. For example, managers who have had enough of the personnel issues that come up too often may seek a position that has no direct reports. Sometimes technical people discover they don’t like project management as much as writing code.

Such is the case with one TechRepublic member who recently wrote to me. He said:

“I currently work as a software development manager but I don’t like the job I’m doing for a lot of reasons. I’ve applied many times for a senior developer position in other companies and had dozens of interviews. All my interviewers were impressed by my development skills but nobody wanted to hire me. Two interviewers asked me: now, you command a large team of developers and testers and you’re a member of the management of your company, are you sure you will accept to be commanded by a (simple) development team leader? I said yes. But I think they didn’t believe me.”

I can understand to some extent the fear of the hiring managers. They don’t want to hire someone who is going to be unchallenged by the role. What I don’t understand is why they can’t take the job candidate’s word at face value.

My guess is that the candidate’s not making himself crystal clear as to the reasons he’d be happy with a less-responsible position. I would prepare a statement that explains why the senior development position is more attractive without being negative about his previous duties. In other words, he shouldn’t say, “I hated management,” but rather, “After a few months in that job, I discovered that what I really missed was the intensity and focus of a purely development role.”

So what about you guys? Have you ever had to “sell yourself” for a position that others deemed below your stature? How’d you handle it?

Toni BowersToni Bowers is the Head Blogs Editor of TechRepublic. She has been in the publishing industry for 20 years, with concentration in IT-related topics. She has edited newsletters, books, and web sites pertaining to software, IT career, and IT management issues.

Print/View all Posts Comments on this blog

I just told them the truth! BBPellet | 06/25/08
Not always a right thing to do batia | 06/26/08
Lying versus omitting..... JamesRL | 06/26/08
Be careful with the details PowerMan2008 | 06/26/08
Lying is hard work.. leketee | 06/27/08
You don't necessarily need to fib. PeteDude | 06/29/08
Major differences there CDubbs | 06/26/08
Just a brief question Slvrknght | 06/27/08
They don't know you . . . IT-->PM | 06/27/08
Thank you Slvrknght | 06/27/08
Golden Rule #1 ben@... | 06/27/08
I agree for different reasons. art@... | 06/27/08
Right On! sbsingleton@... | 06/26/08
Sounds like a good place to work dean.owen | 06/26/08
Hmm MavMin2 | 07/10/08
Telling the truth is more rare today than one might imagine.. rsprague@... | 07/11/08
Maybe MavMin2 | 07/14/08
I applied for the job didn't I Neon Samurai | 06/25/08
Go behind the counter HimDownStairs | 06/25/08
I practiced all week too; "j'want fries with that?", "g'want fries with th Neon Samurai | 06/25/08
A hole in the whole network? jdclyde | 06/26/08
I don't doubt it Neon Samurai | 06/26/08
Happy Medium karey.sayre@... | 07/06/08
Grammer helps desirawson@... | 06/26/08
Grammer??? figglywig@... | 06/26/08
Heheh Slvrknght | 06/27/08
Erm ...I think you mean dyslexics !! OldER Mycroft | 06/27/08
I got a lisdexia meeting later today Neon Samurai | 06/27/08
In The Kitchen MavMin2 | 07/02/08
Yeah, my posting grammar recieves less effort than other documents Neon Samurai | 06/27/08
Casual Writing MavMin2 | 06/30/08
you becha.. Neon Samurai | 06/30/08
That is why you do your resumes in Word and then paste LisaLouLou | 06/30/08
So Does Spelling cory.schultze@... | 06/30/08
I've heard that before MichaelSawyer1969@... | 06/26/08
Overqualified, underspecialized... gsgnt@... | 06/26/08
it's not your qualifications or lack of specialization buckminster@... | 06/27/08
Re: it's not your qualifications or lack of specialization gsgnt@... | 06/30/08
Bang for Buck is true - but not the only factor.. rsprague@... | 07/11/08
What do I think? Is ColdFusion still a meal ticket? Neon Samurai | 06/26/08
Been there, tried that -- didn't work.. rsprague@... | 07/11/08
Couple of thoughts JamesRL | 06/25/08
Good ideas desirawson@... | 06/26/08
what's wrong with that wolfgangs@... | 06/27/08
TG for Wolfgangs MichaelSawyer1969@... | 06/30/08
You may be on to something ben@... | 06/27/08
Great Question! steve@... | 06/25/08
Some of my answers Locrian_Lyric | 06/25/08
Very good! desirawson@... | 06/26/08
RE: How do you convince potential employers that you're not overqualified? mjd420nova | 06/25/08
But they don't want that.. tuomo@... | 06/25/08
It's been my experience.. MichaelSawyer1969@... | 06/26/08
RE: How do you convince potential employers that you're not overqualified? TechG | 06/25/08
RE: How do you convince potential employers that you're not overqualified? Jalapeno Bob | 06/26/08
I agree with Bob MichaelSawyer1969@... | 06/26/08
Too True rm.squires@... | 06/27/08
Make It Obvious. Mark Ryan | 06/26/08
lol! jmacsurf | 06/26/08
Well... Mark Ryan | 06/27/08
I'm Gonna Make It Obvious Tomorrow stwelch@... | 06/27/08
What I've seen is fear dean.owen | 06/26/08
exactly T.Walpole | 06/26/08
Just don't tell them rm.squires@... | 06/27/08
there can be problems in not promoting too. Beoweolf | 06/27/08
I've tried it. It can backfire. robertelliottphd@... | 07/01/08
Did you expose him? mariotrz | 07/01/08
Damn! What a RAT - file a lawsuit? mdiaz@... | 07/03/08
I'd be looking for ways to enlighten the company too Neon Samurai | 07/03/08
HMM MavMin2 | 07/10/08
RE: How do you convince potential employers that you're not overqualified? javadev71@... | 06/26/08
Huh? T.Walpole | 06/26/08
I get what he's saying Menopausal | 06/27/08
RE: How do you convince potential employers that you're not overqualified? zalavijay@... | 06/27/08
A no-win situation paper.bill | 06/27/08
RE: How do you convince potential employers that you're not overqualified? mickeyk@... | 06/27/08
RE: How do you convince potential employers that you're not overqualified? yves@... | 06/27/08
Just a kind rejection MavMin2 | 06/27/08
Very Good Advice stwelch@... | 06/27/08
Excellent reply! chas_2 | 06/27/08
Most often when you are told that you are over qualified No User | 06/27/08
This the one the I never understood... Beoweolf | 06/27/08
This may be why No User | 06/27/08
Re: This the one the I never understood abbi@... | 06/27/08
101% right you are... TekyWanabe | 06/27/08
That's a bit closed-minded. stuffinator@... | 06/28/08
RE: Most often when you are told that you are over qualified MajitoQuerido@... | 06/27/08
less-experienced and tech support. DaemonSlayer | 06/29/08
Hating the Rich or Corporations MavMin2 | 06/30/08
Unions Need to Upgrade bluegalcc@... | 06/30/08
Tech support from India stwelch@... | 06/30/08
part time computer tech KimslanD | 06/27/08
Never had that feeling steelejedi4 | 06/28/08
Catch-22 DaemonSlayer | 06/29/08
T-Shirt MavMin2 | 06/30/08
the "underqualified struggle" mdiaz@... | 06/30/08
RE: How do you convince potential employers that you're not overqualified? garyvdo | 06/27/08
Employers telling the truth? mdiaz@... | 06/27/08
RE: How do you convince potential employers that you're not overqualified? WhitGA | 06/27/08
Learn the game wrlang@... | 06/27/08
RE: Convince employers: I am CIO left to be Project Manager walker.stephen@... | 06/27/08
What I'd like to say, but not in an interview! leolore@... | 06/27/08
Very Insightful...^^Stolen with Pride... thomas.peterson@... | 06/27/08
Great Closing Question stwelch@... | 06/27/08
RE: How do you convince potential employers that you're not overqualified? tekwrytr@... | 06/27/08
The coward's way. Gnuggs | 06/27/08
Change To Another Color stwelch@... | 06/27/08
Careful - you may be a threat? alexp023 | 06/27/08
my rresponse thalilkrazie@... | 06/27/08
Sell to the job... mikifinaz1@... | 06/27/08
Ethnography is all that matter! nouahdnd@... | 06/28/08
Career Retirment raymond@... | 06/28/08
Backfire for employer robertelliottphd@... | 07/01/08
Change Of Lifestyle The Cars Forever | 07/01/08

What do you think?

White Papers, Webcasts, and Downloads

Recent Entries

TR on Twitter

Archives

TechRepublic Blogs



500 Things Every Technology Professional Needs to Know
Did you know Microsoft's RegClean does not work with XP but you can use shareware to clean your registry? Did you know most wireless access points don't have encryption enabled by default? Did you know there are 500 tidbits of information contained in TechRepublic's 500 Things Every Technology Professional Needs to Know that will help you become a successful IT professional.
Buy Now
Quick Reference: Linux Commands
Reduce stress and speed up resolutions with the easiest command references right at your fingertips. You'll receive a PDF file covering Linux, packed with the most common commands you'll need and use daily.
Buy Now

SmartPlanet

Click Here